Rules Catalog

vigil V0 includes 26 rules across 4 categories. Each rule has a unique ID, default severity, and references to security standards where applicable.

To list all rules from the terminal:

vigil rules

---

CAT-01: Dependency Hallucination

Status: IMPLEMENTED — The DependencyAnalyzer is active. Rules DEP-001, DEP-002, DEP-003, DEP-005, and DEP-007 are implemented. DEP-004 and DEP-006 are deferred to a future version.

Detects hallucinated dependencies (slopsquatting), typosquatting, and suspicious packages. This is vigil’s primary differentiator — no other scanner verifies that dependencies actually exist.

DEP-001 — Hallucinated dependency

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL
OWASP	LLM03 — Supply Chain Vulnerabilities
CWE	CWE-829 — Inclusion of Functionality from Untrusted Control Sphere

What it detects: A package declared as a dependency does not exist in the public registry (PyPI or npm).

Why it is critical: LLMs frequently generate package names that sound plausible but don’t exist. An attacker can register that name with malicious code (slopsquatting). When someone runs pip install or npm install, they install the malicious package.

Vulnerable code example:

# requirements.txt
flask==3.0.0
python-jwt-utils==1.0.0    # This package does NOT exist on PyPI
requests==2.31.0

How to fix: Search PyPI/npm for the correct package. In this case, the agent probably meant PyJWT or python-jose.

---

DEP-002 — Suspiciously new dependency

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
OWASP	LLM03

What it detects: The package exists but was published less than 30 days ago (configurable with deps.min_age_days).

Why it matters: New packages haven’t had time to be audited by the community. They could be malicious packages registered as part of a slopsquatting attack.

Example: A package created 3 days ago with a useful-sounding name (fast-json-parser) that no one has reviewed.

How to fix: Manually verify the package: review the source code, the maintainer, the purpose. If it is legitimate, add an exception in the config.

---

DEP-003 — Typosquatting candidate

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
OWASP	LLM03
CWE	CWE-829

What it detects: The package name is very similar to a popular package (normalized Levenshtein distance >= 0.85).

Vulnerable code example:

# requirements.txt
reqeusts==2.31.0     # Typo of "requests"

How to fix: Verify the correct package name. In the suggestion, vigil indicates which popular package it resembles.

---

DEP-004 — Unpopular dependency (pending)

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM
Status	Deferred — requires download statistics API

What it detects: The package has fewer than 100 weekly downloads (configurable with deps.min_weekly_downloads).

Why it matters: Packages with very few downloads may be abandoned, have unpatched vulnerabilities, or be an indicator of a fake package.

---

DEP-005 — No source repository

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM

What it detects: The package does not have a source code repository linked in its metadata.

Why it matters: Without access to the source code, it is impossible to audit what the package does. Legitimate packages almost always have a linked repository.

---

DEP-006 — Missing dependency (pending)

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
Status	Deferred — requires AST import parser

What it detects: An import in the code references a module that is not declared in the project’s dependencies.

Vulnerable code example:

# src/app.py
import magical_orm    # Not in requirements.txt or pyproject.toml

def get_users():
    return magical_orm.query("SELECT * FROM users")

---

DEP-007 — Nonexistent version

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL

What it detects: The specified version of the package does not exist in the registry.

Vulnerable code example:

# requirements.txt
flask==99.0.0        # This version does not exist

---

CAT-02: Auth & Permission Patterns

Status: IMPLEMENTED — The AuthAnalyzer is active since v0.3.0. All rules AUTH-001 through AUTH-007 are implemented. Supports Python (FastAPI/Flask) and JavaScript (Express).

Detects insecure authentication and authorization patterns that AI agents frequently generate.

AUTH-001 — Unprotected sensitive endpoint

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
OWASP	LLM06 — Excessive Agency
CWE	CWE-306 — Missing Authentication for Critical Function

What it detects: An endpoint that handles sensitive data (users, payments, admin) without authentication middleware.

Vulnerable code example (FastAPI):

@app.get("/users/{user_id}")
async def get_user(user_id: int):    # No Depends(get_current_user)
    return db.get_user(user_id)

---

AUTH-002 — Destructive endpoint without authorization

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
CWE	CWE-862 — Missing Authorization

What it detects: A DELETE or PUT endpoint without authorization verification.

Vulnerable code example:

@app.delete("/users/{user_id}")
async def delete_user(user_id: int):    # Anyone can delete users
    db.delete_user(user_id)
    return {"deleted": user_id}

---

AUTH-003 — Excessive token lifetime

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM

What it detects: JWT with a lifetime greater than 24 hours (configurable with auth.max_token_lifetime_hours).

Vulnerable code example:

token = jwt.encode(
    {"exp": datetime.utcnow() + timedelta(hours=72)},  # 72 hours
    SECRET_KEY
)

---

AUTH-004 — Hardcoded JWT secret

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL
CWE	CWE-798 — Use of Hard-coded Credentials

What it detects: A hardcoded JWT secret with a placeholder value or low entropy.

Vulnerable code example:

SECRET_KEY = "supersecret123"    # Hardcoded and predictable
token = jwt.encode(payload, SECRET_KEY)

---

AUTH-005 — CORS allow all origins

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
CWE	CWE-942 — Permissive Cross-domain Policy

What it detects: CORS configured with * allowing requests from any origin.

Vulnerable code example:

# FastAPI
app.add_middleware(CORSMiddleware, allow_origins=["*"])

# Express
app.use(cors())    # No options = allow all

---

AUTH-006 — Insecure cookie configuration

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM
CWE	CWE-614 — Sensitive Cookie in HTTPS Session Without ‘Secure’ Attribute

What it detects: Cookies without the httpOnly, secure, or sameSite security flags.

---

AUTH-007 — Password comparison not timing-safe

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM
CWE	CWE-208 — Observable Timing Discrepancy

What it detects: Password comparison using == instead of a constant-time comparison function.

Vulnerable code example:

if user.password == provided_password:    # Vulnerable to timing attacks
    return True

Fix:

import hmac
if hmac.compare_digest(user.password_hash, computed_hash):
    return True

---

CAT-03: Secrets & Credentials

Status: IMPLEMENTED — The SecretsAnalyzer is active since v0.3.0. Rules SEC-001 through SEC-004 and SEC-006 are implemented. SEC-005 is deferred (requires .gitignore analysis). Supports Python and JavaScript/TypeScript.

Detects secrets and credentials that AI agents copy from examples or generate insecurely.

SEC-001 — Placeholder secret in code

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL
CWE	CWE-798

What it detects: A value that looks like a placeholder copied from .env.example or documentation.

Vulnerable code example:

API_KEY = "your-api-key-here"      # Copied placeholder
DATABASE_URL = "changeme"           # Placeholder

---

SEC-002 — Low-entropy hardcoded secret

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL
CWE	CWE-798

What it detects: A hardcoded secret with low entropy (likely generated carelessly by the AI agent).

Example: SECRET = "abc123" has much lower entropy than a real secret.

---

SEC-003 — Embedded connection string

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL
CWE	CWE-798

What it detects: Connection strings with embedded credentials.

Vulnerable code example:

DATABASE_URL = "postgresql://admin:password123@db.example.com:5432/mydb"
MONGO_URI = "mongodb://root:secret@mongo:27017/app"

---

SEC-004 — Sensitive env with default value

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH

What it detects: A sensitive environment variable with a hardcoded default value in the code.

Vulnerable code example:

SECRET_KEY = os.getenv("SECRET_KEY", "fallback-secret-not-for-production")

---

SEC-005 — Secret file not in gitignore (pending)

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH
Status	Deferred — requires .gitignore analysis

What it detects: Files that contain credentials or keys and are not listed in .gitignore.

Typical files: .env, credentials.json, *.pem, *.key

---

SEC-006 — Value copied from env example

Field	Value
Severity	CRITICAL

What it detects: A value in the code that textually matches a value from the .env.example file.

Example: If .env.example has API_KEY=sk-example-key-12345 and the code has api_key = "sk-example-key-12345", vigil detects it.

---

CAT-06: Test Quality

Status: PENDING — Rules TEST-001 through TEST-006 are defined but the TestQualityAnalyzer is not yet implemented (PHASE 3).

Detects tests that provide false coverage — they pass but don’t verify anything real. This is known as “test theater”.

TEST-001 — Test without assertions

Field	Value
Severity	HIGH

What it detects: A test function that contains no assert, verify, expect, or similar statement.

Vulnerable code example:

def test_login():
    response = client.post("/login", json={"user": "admin", "pass": "123"})
    # No assert — the test always passes

---

TEST-002 — Trivial assertion

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM

What it detects: An assert that only verifies trivial conditions like is not None or assertTrue(True).

Vulnerable code example:

def test_user_exists():
    user = get_user(1)
    assert user is not None    # Trivial: doesn't verify the content

---

TEST-003 — Assert catches all exceptions

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM

What it detects: Tests that use except Exception: pass or except: pass, hiding real errors.

Vulnerable code example:

def test_complex_operation():
    try:
        result = complex_operation()
    except Exception:    # Catches everything, the test never fails
        pass

---

TEST-004 — Skipped test without reason

Field	Value
Severity	LOW

What it detects: Tests marked with @pytest.mark.skip or @unittest.skip without a reason argument.

---

TEST-005 — No status code assertion in API test

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM

What it detects: Tests that make HTTP requests but don’t verify the response status code.

---

TEST-006 — Mock mirrors implementation

Field	Value
Severity	MEDIUM

What it detects: Mocks whose return value is exactly the value the test expects, creating a circular test that doesn’t verify real logic.

Vulnerable code example:

def test_calculate():
    with patch("app.calculate") as mock:
        mock.return_value = 42        # The mock returns 42
        result = app.calculate(6, 7)
        assert result == 42           # ...and the test expects 42. Nothing was tested.